snowprint/halloween-test
1
0
Fork 0
Code Issues Pull Requests Actions Packages Projects Releases Wiki Activity

fix(spec): resolve edge case clarifications from analysis

Browse Source 
Resolved 2 LOW severity issues identified in /analyze:

Issue C1 - Edge Case Clarifications:
- Updated line 51: Countdown zero behavior → "🎃 EVENT STARTING NOW! 🎃"
- Updated line 53: Post-event behavior → "👻 EVENT COMPLETED - Thanks for joining! 👻"
- Removed [NEEDS CLARIFICATION] markers
- Added all 4 edge case resolutions to Notes section

Issue C2 - Documentation Consistency:
- Updated "Clarifications Needed" → "Edge Case Resolutions"
- Marked requirement completeness checklist as complete
- Updated execution status: "Ambiguities marked" → "Ambiguities resolved"
- Updated review status: "with 2 minor clarifications needed" → "all checks complete"

Edge cases now fully specified:
1. Countdown reaches zero → Display event starting message
2. After event ends (21:00 GMT+8) → Display completion message
3. JavaScript disabled → Show fallback message, static content accessible
4. Very small screens (< 320px) → Use ultra-minimal ASCII art

All decisions sourced from plan.md edge case resolutions (L185-188).

Analysis summary:
- 100% requirement coverage (35/35)
- 0 critical/high/medium issues
- 2 low issues → RESOLVED
- Ready for implementation

🤖 Generated with [Claude Code](https://claude.com/claude-code)

Co-Authored-By: Claude <noreply@anthropic.com>
This commit is contained in:
snowprint
2025-10-04 19:30:15 +08:00
parent 3b355148b7
commit c2338e307a
1 changed files with 10 additions and 8 deletions
Download Patch File Download Diff File Expand all files Collapse all files

18
specs/001-mcdonald-s-it/spec.md
View File

@@ -48,9 +48,9 @@ As a McDonald's China IT team member, I want to view the Halloween 2025 event an
4. **Given** a team member reads event information, **When** they scroll through the page, **Then** they can find event date (Oct 31 2025), time (18:00-21:00), location (MITA Building 2F Pantry), activities (cosplay, debugging games, lucky draw), and organizer contact (jessi.pan@cn.mcd.com) 4. **Given** a team member reads event information, **When** they scroll through the page, **Then** they can find event date (Oct 31 2025), time (18:00-21:00), location (MITA Building 2F Pantry), activities (cosplay, debugging games, lucky draw), and organizer contact (jessi.pan@cn.mcd.com)
### Edge Cases ### Edge Cases
- What happens when the countdown reaches zero? [NEEDS CLARIFICATION: Should display "Event Started" or "Event Ended" message] - What happens when the countdown reaches zero? Display "🎃 EVENT STARTING NOW! 🎃" message
- How does ASCII art render on very small screens (< 320px)? System must provide mobile-optimized version - How does ASCII art render on very small screens (< 320px)? System must provide mobile-optimized version
- What happens if user visits after event date? [NEEDS CLARIFICATION: Should page remain active or show "Event Completed" message] - What happens if user visits after event date? Display "👻 EVENT COMPLETED - Thanks for joining! 👻" message after Oct 31 2025 21:00 GMT+8
- What if JavaScript is disabled? Countdown won't work but all static content must remain accessible - What if JavaScript is disabled? Countdown won't work but all static content must remain accessible
## Requirements *(mandatory)* ## Requirements *(mandatory)*
@@ -124,7 +124,7 @@ As a McDonald's China IT team member, I want to view the Halloween 2025 event an
- [x] All mandatory sections completed - [x] All mandatory sections completed
### Requirement Completeness ### Requirement Completeness
- [ ] No [NEEDS CLARIFICATION] markers remain (2 edge cases need clarification) - [x] No [NEEDS CLARIFICATION] markers remain
- [x] Requirements are testable and unambiguous - [x] Requirements are testable and unambiguous
- [x] Success criteria are measurable - [x] Success criteria are measurable
- [x] Scope is clearly bounded - [x] Scope is clearly bounded
@@ -137,19 +137,21 @@ As a McDonald's China IT team member, I want to view the Halloween 2025 event an
- [x] User description parsed - [x] User description parsed
- [x] Key concepts extracted - [x] Key concepts extracted
- [x] Ambiguities marked (2 edge cases) - [x] Ambiguities resolved (all edge cases clarified)
- [x] User scenarios defined - [x] User scenarios defined
- [x] Requirements generated (35 functional requirements) - [x] Requirements generated (35 functional requirements)
- [x] Entities identified (3 key entities) - [x] Entities identified (3 key entities)
- [x] Review checklist passed (with 2 minor clarifications needed) - [x] Review checklist passed (all checks complete)
--- ---
## Notes ## Notes
**Clarifications Needed:** **Edge Case Resolutions:**
1. Post-countdown behavior: What should display when countdown reaches zero? 1. Post-countdown behavior: Display "🎃 EVENT STARTING NOW! 🎃" message when countdown reaches zero
2. Post-event behavior: Should page remain active or show completion message after Oct 31 2025? 2. Post-event behavior: Display "👻 EVENT COMPLETED - Thanks for joining! 👻" message after Oct 31 2025 21:00 GMT+8
3. JavaScript disabled: All static content remains accessible with fallback message "Enable JavaScript for live countdown"
4. Very small screens (< 320px): Use ultra-minimal ASCII art (simplified version) prioritizing readability
**Design Philosophy:** **Design Philosophy:**
- Extreme minimalism inspired by Homebrew package manager aesthetic - Extreme minimalism inspired by Homebrew package manager aesthetic